McAfee was also the primary punter for West Virginia in both 2007 and 2008. For his career, he averaged 43.7 yards per punt on 126 punts.
Following his senior season, McAfee was invited to participate in the 2009 Senior Bowl, where he went 5-for-5 on extra point attempts in the South team's win.
McAfee served as the Colts punter and kickoff specialist in 2009. He finished the regular season 20th in the NFL in net punting average, then punted 10 times in the Colts two playoff wins leading up to Super Bowl XLIV. McAfee punted twice for an average of 45.0 yards in the Colts Super Bowl loss to the Saints.
McAfee has also performed as a professional wrestler, winning his debut in IWA East Coast Wrestling in March of 2009.